Isn't it intolerant to say that Christianity is the only true religion?
Dig Deeper
- If Jesus is the only way, then what about those who never hear about him, like remote indigenous tribes or Muslim majority countries?
- But still, isn't it at least narrow-minded to say that Christianity is the only way?
- Isn't it possible that all religions are just different "roads" that lead up to the top of the same mountain? Why does only Christianity have to be true?
- I don't think you can be confident about any religious claim. We can't possibly be confident about these things.
I hope you found that video helpful and caught their sense of humor around the idea of intolerance.
So to summarize the video, disagreeing with someone doesn't make you intolerant - if anything, it's what allows you to be tolerant of someone else since tolerance doesn't mean you have to give up your beliefs, but rather give the other person the right to disagree. If you have no disagreements with other people, there's nothing to tolerate!
Saying I believe something to be true simultaneously means that I believe the opposite to be false, and if it's the case that it's intolerant to claim another person's beliefs as false, then the only way I can have this type of "tolerance" is if I don't believe anything to be true! That would make life pretty difficult!
I'd also like to point out as that the person who thinks that religions are intolerant or arrogant for claiming to be correct is, under that definition, guilty of the same arrogance! Because what are they assuming? That they themselves are right, and every exclusive religion is wrong! In other words they're making an exclusive and therefore "arrogant" claim by dismissing religion's exclusive beliefs. So it's a self-defeating objection.
But maybe that leaves you thinking: How could you possibly be confident enough to believe you're right about something mysterious like religion and believe that so many others are wrong? Wouldn't that classify as arrogance, or at least over-confidence?
First, that's understandable, especially because we often don't associate religion with evidence or logic, but with "faith" and subjective feelings. But I'd like to suggest that if we had real, rational reasons and evidence for the Christian faith, that confidence would be justified. Second, it's possible to be confident without being arrogant, and confidence doesn’t always mean arrogance. I'll admit not everyone you meet is open-minded or humble, but a core belief of the Christian faith is that Christians are no better than others, and humility is the core virtue that Christians are called to.
If you'd like to learn about the evidence that Christians can be confident about for their faith, such as the evidence for the existence of God and the evidence for the resurrection of Jesus, feel free to explore the rest of this site. But if you have other follow-up questions, feel free to stay on this page.
Dig Deeper
- If Jesus is the only way, then what about those who never hear about him, like remote indigenous tribes or Muslim majority countries?
- But still, isn't it at least narrow-minded to say that Christianity is the only way?
- Isn't it possible that all religions are just different "roads" that lead up to the top of the same mountain? Why does only Christianity have to be true?
- I don't think you can be confident about any religious claim. We can't possibly be confident about these things.